Skip navigation

Saturday Paper: Court backs Victoria’s ‘loophole logging’

A bid to hold the Victorian government to account for ‘loophole logging’ – which activists claim is destroying old-growth habitat for endangered mammals – has failed.

On an autumn morning in 2024, wildlife surveyor Blake Nesbit found the still-warm body of a glider flattened within logging machine tread-tracks on the forest floor at Yarra Ranges National Park. He called Jordan Crook, vice-president of Wildlife of the Central Highlands.

“I felt sickened,” Crook tells The Saturday Paper. “Blake was crying. He said: ‘They killed a glider.’ It was in one of the trees we’d told them [the government] about. This was just one critter we knew about.”

Protected under federal law, the greater glider had been uplisted from “vulnerable” to “endangered”, with remaining numbers unknown. Allegedly killed by a swig machine, the glider became pivotal to Warburton Environment Inc v DEECA, or the “Hollows case”, a Federal Court test case against “loophole logging” by Victoria’s Department of Energy, Environment and Climate Action.

After years of litigation with mixed results, optimism was high on Thursday in a courtroom overflowing with conservationists. That is, until Justice Christopher Horan dismissed all claims. “It was not established that there were significant impacts on the greater glider or Leadbeater’s possum,” he said, and there was “insufficient basis” to conclude significant impacts in future.

The ruling coincides with breaking news that Victoria’s lowland Leadbeater’s possum has been declared “extinct in the wild” due to forestry and invasive species mismanagement. It’s an expert classification rejected by the government.

The implications of Thursday’s outcome are yet to be fully analysed, Warburton Environment president Nic Fox said outside court, but forest groups will “keep fighting”.

“It’s been such a hard campaign,” she tells The Saturday Paper. “How do you fight a case against something that the government claims doesn’t exist?”

Fox is referring to state government claims that “loophole logging” doesn’t exist. She says a Hollows case argument was that Forest Fire Management Victoria’s (FFMVic) “sudden increase” in removal of habitat trees “does not correspond with a sudden increase in the severity of the hazard they pose” but “does correspond with a sudden increase in funding for tree removal contractors previously retained by VicForests [Victoria’s defunct logging company]”.

The litigants sought to compel FFMVic to heed the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation (EPBC) Act, which was designed to protect species on the pathway to extinction. Evidence mostly centred around more than 800 towering, hollow-bearing trees that Wurundjeri custodian Stacie Piper calls “our baban darrang, our grandmother trees, our ancient ones”.

Recognised as essential keystone species, without which ecosystem function would collapse, the trees measured up to 2.85 metres wide. Centuries old, they safeguarded the rainforest “long before colonisation”, Piper tells The Saturday Paper.

In early 2024, DEECA staff spray-painted them with pink circles and perpendicular “slash lines”, marking them for felling.

By then, logging had officially ended, but former VicForests staff were absorbed into FFMVic, which maintained that continued felling was necessary for “forest management” and “community safety”. VicForests had scheduled roughly 4000 hectares annually for logging until 2030; FFMVic replaced this with equivalent deforestation – an additional 6000 kilometres of clearings, some up to 40 metres wide, for “fuel breaks”.

Even after successful lawsuits against VicForests, FFMVic felling proved impossible to legally challenge. It was not bound by the “already weak” state laws governing VicForests, explains Fox. FFMVic could deforest national parks “with impunity”, bypassing federal laws with “community safety” pretexts. Nor was FFMVic accountable to the Office of the Conservation Regulator.

“State and federal governments are failing threatened species. Without community groups documenting this destruction and challenging it in court, who is holding the state government to account?”

Continue Reading

Read More